Wednesday, October 19, 2016
I have written thousands of words in this blog explaining what I believe is solid evidence that the nationwide move to privatize our public education system is a huge mistake. I have pointed out in many posts the overwhelming evidence that privatizing education through the use of charter schools and voucher schools is generally counterproductive, does not improve education, and opens up the funding of public education to fraud and abuse. Not all charter schools are bad and not all schools that accept vouchers are bad, but I believe the concept of allowing our public school taxes to go to unregulated and unsupervised private groups is a bad idea.
Please don't believe all of the horrible stuff you have heard over the last 10 years about Louisiana having failing public schools. There will always be some schools that are not doing the best they should be doing for our children, but I truly believe that any student who is motivated and works hard will receive a great education in our public schools. Sure, we have schools where students score below average on state and national tests but that can be much more accurately ascribed to the rate of poverty of the students and their families. In almost all cases efforts of the teachers and administrators in so called "failing schools" is extremely caring and almost heroic despite the unfair criticism our warped system of accountability heaps on them each year. Our public schools in Louisiana provide all children with a path to success if they just are willing and able to take advantage of what is being offered.
Unfortunately, our public schools have had very poor leadership at the state and national levels in the last 10 years because of an extremely misguided reform movement that has pushed an ineffective college prep "for all" program and that has promoted all forms of privatization over the support of our public schools. But my research for the past 10 years shows conclusively that charter schools and voucher schools often do not give our taxpayer's their money's worth. Again I repeat, there are a few such schools that really do a good job, and I have personal knowledge of such schools and their success, but the overall effect of privatization encourages fraud and abuse of our tax dollars and does not do justice to most students. You need only to look at the results of privatization of schools in Chile to see the end result of privatization. That country is now facing a major effort to reverse the destructive results of privatization.
It is with the above principles in mind that I would like to strongly recommend Foster Campbell for the U.S. Senate and Hillary Clinton for President.
I have personally known Foster Campbell for over 30 years and have always found him to be a true supporter of public education. Foster respects the teaching profession and would never recommend national policies that would force half-baked education reforms over the recommendations of our educators and parents. He does not support the current privatization move and will instead work hard to strengthen our public school system and elevate the teaching profession.
Now for the big one! In all my many years of involvement in the democratic process for election of our leaders have I ever seen a more important decision for the office of president.
I want to start by making clear that I do not believe Hillary Clinton is a perfect candidate. She has in the past been misled to some extent by the propaganda that has so effectively promoted charter schools as a magic solution. But I believe that she has great respect for the teaching profession and will listen to reason on major issues relating to privatization and support for the profession. I believe much of the criticism of Mrs. Clinton has been exaggerated by the tremendous partisanship of our current two party system which seems to value party success over the welfare of our nation.
I will just make one small point in contradiction to what I believe has been unfair criticism of Mrs. Clinton when she was Secretary of State. Republicans have spent millions of our tax dollars investigating the Bengazi incident where 4 courageous and loyal American public servants were viscously murdered by terrorists. It is alleged that Clinton was negligent in not providing adequate security and in not rescuing the victims. The problem is hindsight is 20:20. Certainly now we can see that more should have been done, but I will never believe for one minute that Secretary Clinton did not care sincerely for the wellbeing of these dedicated individuals. I just want to make one comparison: Years ago, president Reagan was warned repeatedly by security professionals that is was not wise to maintain a base in Lebanon for U.S. Marines. He ignored these warnings and our security system was not able to prevent a huge bomb from being driven to the marine barracks which resulted in the horrible deaths of over 250 marines. Our nation was horrified, and Reagan very quickly closed the base and moved the rest of our troops out of harms way. But the difference, is our congressional leaders did not choose to have endless investigations and second guessing of the mistakes by Reagan and his appointed leaders that may have prevented this catastrophe. Now, the political climate is such that every mistake of our present leadership is always blown out of proportion.
I repeat: Hillary Clinton is not perfect, but I believe she is extremely well qualified to be president of the United States, is highly respected by the world community and will always attempt to do what is best for our country and the world in general. I do not believe the same can be said for Donald Trump.
One of the major reasons I believe it would be a serious mistake for the citizens and voters of the United States of America to elect Donald Trump is that he obviously knows nothing about elementary/secondary schools, but he has stated repeatedly that he wants to remove all barriers to expansion of both charters and vouchers with our public taxes. The national Republican party also has a solid position promoting the expansion of both charter schools and vouchers.
But there are other very important reasons why Trump should not be elected president. So much of what we have seen and heard from Trump himself and from persons who have had dealings with Trump over the years show him to be unprincipled, dishonest, deceptive, greedy, hypocritical, and unworthy of our trust as president of our great country. Trump is obviously a pathological liar as evidenced by his promotion of the Birther Movement against president Obama, his outlandish claims about his Republican opponents, his attacks on Hillary Clinton, the media and the Republican leadership. His proposals to ban immigrants, to torture prisoners, to murder the families of radical Islamist enemies, and to simultaneously be an isolationist and to be a war monger would certainly destabilize international relations. His vow to banish 16 million people, most of whom are good people, and who contribute greatly to the workforce of the construction industry and farming industry in this country, according to most economists, would quickly deal a severe blow to our economy.
Trump has been one of the worst examples of the abuse of our American economy by the privileged class. We have no reason to believe that he will change and somehow become a good leader for all the citizens our country.
Please consider voting for Hillary Clinton for President and Foster Campbell for U. S. Senator.
Posted by Michael Deshotels