School attendance reports for the first half of the 2009-2010 school year for East Baton Rouge Parish public schools reveal that approximately 9,366 students out of a total enrollment of 45,000 missed at least 6 school days during the first semester. Yet that was an improvement of 12% over the previous school year when over 10,000 students missed over 5 days the first semester. These statistics indicate that on average approximately 22 percent of all students in the East Baton Rouge school system are almost certainly headed for failure solely because of excessive absences! Superintendent Dilworth with the help of the EBR District Attorney’s office is determined to change the mind set of parents and students who ignore the mandatory attendance law. (Click on this link to see The Advocate article on Truancy) That’s why parents of such students are being notified of the requirements of the law and are invited to attend special workshops on student attendance.
Since the “Early Warning Meetings” were instituted in the first semester of this school year, student absences for the month of January 2010 have been reduced by 40% compared to last year according to EBR spokesperson Chris Trahan. This improved result may be due to the wording of the letter sent to parents of habitually absent students notifying parents of the very real fines and community service or jail time for parents who fail to comply with the mandatory attendance law. Many parents seemed to be unaware of their child’s absences or of the serious consequences for both students and parents of students who are deemed to be habitually absent or tardy.
One of the most successful cooperative programs between the local District Attorney’s office and public school systems has been in operation for approximately 10 years in Bossier and Webster Parishes. Project administrator Richey Jackson of the District attorney’s office believes that such a program is especially effective in urban school systems. The program he administers also funds coordinators who enforce the community service requirements of the law for both students and parents. This program works because it has enforcement teeth according to Mr Jackson who has long been a champion of enforcing accountability for parents.
Recently, District and Family Court judges in the Bossier/Webster area have been imposing increasingly stiff penalties on parents and juveniles who violate the compulsory attendance law.
The only major flaw in the system according to Jackson, is that some parents are taking advantage of the Home Study laws to avoid the requirements of the mandatory school attendance laws. He believes that if Louisiana continues to allow home schooling, the program must be strictly monitored to insure that students are actually receiving effective instruction.
This writer believes it is high time Accountability for school attendance was strictly enforced in all public school systems. It is impractical and unfair to hold school administrators and teachers solely responsible for educating students over whom they have no control. No teacher can teach an empty desk!
BESE loses an Independent Voice: Last week, Tammie McDaniel, one of the Governor’s appointees to BESE resigned and was replaced by a person who works as a private school administrator. McDaniel had been under intense pressure for over a year because of her questioning of the policies of State Superintendent Pastorek. She had become increasingly critical of State and Federal mandates and what she saw as state and Federal encroachment on local authority for operation of public schools. This is a serious loss for public education.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Thursday, February 11, 2010
BESE Pressured by Charter Advocates
The campaign to convert Louisiana public schools to charter schools run by various private groups continues to intensify. A most recent example is an editorial in the Greater Baton Rouge Business Report by editor Rolfe McCollister Jr titled Is BESE a puppet for school boards? The editorial attacks some BESE members for their reluctance to approve type II Charter schools that were not recommended for approval by local school systems. McCollister whose daughter works for one of the organizations now running a group of charter schools in the Baton Rouge area is hardly an unbiased commentator on the charter issue. But neither is the State Superintendent of Education and even the U S Secretary of Education Arne Duncan or Governor Jindal for that matter. Much of the Race to the Top project is based on conversion of public schools to charters.
The word is going around among the pro business elite and even church groups and African American activist groups such as 100 Black Men, that charter schools are the answer to turning around low performing schools. Some of these groups are being courted by professional “for profit” charter groups like the Edison Schools to serve as “front” organizations for the takeover of schools. And Louisiana, with its many low performing schools, is seen by these special interests as the perfect proving grounds for the charter movement.
One might ask: “What does it matter who turns around a low performing school? The only important thing is that students get a better education. Since local school systems have "botched" the job of improving the performance of their students, don’t they deserve to have those failing schools taken over?”
The answer is obvious: We should be willing to do whatever it takes to improve Louisiana schools even if it means giving up control to charter groups. However, just because charter schools are the latest fad in education does not make them effective. BESE has the responsibility to study carefully the actual results produced by charter schools and other Recovery District schools and base their decisions on facts, not political pressure by either school boards or charter school advocates.
That’s what this link to An Analysis of Recent Recovery District School Performance does. It provides the facts based on data collected by the Department of Education Accountability system and an analysis of Charter Schools in the Baton Rouge area by an independent evaluation company. This report was sent to BESE several months ago and should be considered when decisions are made on future charter proposals. I urge all persons interested in improving education in Louisiana to download and print this report. Feel free to make it available to other educators, interested citizens and to the news media in your area.
There is no question that many of our public schools can and should be improved. This report shows that more progress is being made in this effort by our locally run school systems with their democratically elected school boards than by these private charter groups or by the State run Recovery District.
The problem is the facts are being ignored or distorted by a small number of special interests who use their influence with the media to promote their agenda. Public school professionals can only blame themselves if this misinformation is not corrected.
The word is going around among the pro business elite and even church groups and African American activist groups such as 100 Black Men, that charter schools are the answer to turning around low performing schools. Some of these groups are being courted by professional “for profit” charter groups like the Edison Schools to serve as “front” organizations for the takeover of schools. And Louisiana, with its many low performing schools, is seen by these special interests as the perfect proving grounds for the charter movement.
One might ask: “What does it matter who turns around a low performing school? The only important thing is that students get a better education. Since local school systems have "botched" the job of improving the performance of their students, don’t they deserve to have those failing schools taken over?”
The answer is obvious: We should be willing to do whatever it takes to improve Louisiana schools even if it means giving up control to charter groups. However, just because charter schools are the latest fad in education does not make them effective. BESE has the responsibility to study carefully the actual results produced by charter schools and other Recovery District schools and base their decisions on facts, not political pressure by either school boards or charter school advocates.
That’s what this link to An Analysis of Recent Recovery District School Performance does. It provides the facts based on data collected by the Department of Education Accountability system and an analysis of Charter Schools in the Baton Rouge area by an independent evaluation company. This report was sent to BESE several months ago and should be considered when decisions are made on future charter proposals. I urge all persons interested in improving education in Louisiana to download and print this report. Feel free to make it available to other educators, interested citizens and to the news media in your area.
There is no question that many of our public schools can and should be improved. This report shows that more progress is being made in this effort by our locally run school systems with their democratically elected school boards than by these private charter groups or by the State run Recovery District.
The problem is the facts are being ignored or distorted by a small number of special interests who use their influence with the media to promote their agenda. Public school professionals can only blame themselves if this misinformation is not corrected.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Providing School Choice
Allowing parents to choose the school to be attended for their child's education is gaining popularity among parents and voters. Each year we see efforts to allow vouchers aimed at providing public funding for children who attend private schools. The biggest push today is for establishing privately run Charter schools that receive per pupil allotments from the state MFP and local school system funds.
An important question is: Does the current movement for “Choice” in Louisiana really provide students and their parents with appropriate choices for the education of all students?
An analysis of recent trends in education policy decisions in Louisiana reveals that instead of allowing parents more choice, the State Government is increasingly mandating what all children should learn in minute detail. Parents can expect less choice and fewer varied opportunities for their child’s education in the foreseeable future. The fact is that the school curriculum and even specific teaching approaches are becoming more standardized whether the student attends a traditional public school or a public Charter school. The Louisiana Comprehensive Curriculum now mandates almost every single concept (GLE) to be taught at each grade. But if that’s not enough Government control, Louisiana is set to participate in a Common Core Standards effort led by the National Governor’s Association to implement a standard curriculum in all public schools in participating states within the next few years. The stated goal is to insure that all students completing an elementary/secondary education graduate “College and Career” ready. As we have seen from the January 29 posting on this blog, this amounts to an attempt to provide College prep training for all.
The assumption has been made, even though contradicted by many years of education experience, that every student can and should master all the same concepts of language arts, math and science at the same rate and with the same proficiency. Basically the State and National Governments are in the business of deciding exactly what each child needs to know. And it’s the same for every child at every step of the education ladder. Also, in Louisiana every public school is mandated by the state to produce its quota of “proficient” students as measured by the School Performance Scores (SPS). Every public school in Louisiana was mandated by BESE to reach an SPS of 100 by the end of the 2009 school year (it didn’t happen) and all schools are expected to reach an SPS of 120 by the end of the 2014 school year (it won’t happen).
Government mandates and quotas are not new. When Communism in the Soviet Union was in its heyday, every factory had quotas of standardized products to produce. The Government set all the rules and quotas for industrial production and for education. It turned out that Government was not successful in dictating a productive economy, and the poorly organized Russian economy helped bring down the Communist system along with the breakup of the Soviet Union. Socialism could not match the free markets in industrial production or in education.
Yet today Louisiana and many other states seem intent on applying the concepts of Socialism to our public education system. Louisiana’s state-set goals and quotas are producing the same disappointing results as did the Socialist quotas. As we discussed in last week’s blog, Louisiana is trying to churn out more 4 year college grads at a time when we should be concentrating on skilled trades, technical and service careers. Instead of letting market forces and individual students and parents decide what careers are appropriate, Louisiana has instituted a quota system for public education. 72% of our students are expected to master the Core IV curriculum. Every student is expected to master Algebra even if he/she will never again work an Algebra problem after leaving High School. (If he can’t do Algebra, he can’t get a high school diploma even if he has marketable talents in other areas). Even after the overwhelming “yes” vote in the legislature for the Career Diploma law, our state Dept. of Education refuses to allow students a real opportunity to begin learning a skill or trade before leaving high school. As a result, over 20,000 students each year leave our public education system with no high school diploma and with no useful job training. Yet our education bureaucracy seems to never tire of setting new quotas (72% Core 4, 120 SPS for all schools) even while rolling back some of the biggest failures such as the mandate requiring retention of 4th graders who did not measure up on LEAP.
By contrast, the nation of Finland is recognized as a world leader in the education of all its students.. (Click on the highlighted link to see a description of the Finland education system in Wikipedia). Finland has close to the top world ranking in math, language and science, yet a large proportion of students are allowed to begin vocational training at age 15. Most Finnish students who enter vocational education in high school are career ready within 3 or 4 years. Louisiana students by contrast, if they are not academically inclined, are required to continue struggling with the state mandated college prep curriculum until they flunk out or drop out of high school. (click on the link for a more detailed critique of Louisiana’s Accountability System) As a result Louisiana consistently has 42% of its students getting almost no marketable skills. I’ve come to the conclusion that Louisiana does have a two track system. I call it College Prep and Jail Prep! Unfortunately, we’re doing too good job with the Jail Prep. Just look at the educational attainment of young offenders in our correctional institutions. By contrast almost all students in Finland are either fully prepared for a career or college upon leaving high school.
I believe the proper role of state government in education should be to facilitate (not mandate) a system where all local schools provide a solid college prep program and an equally effective vocational or career program starting at the 9th grade level. That’s because once students pass the age of 14 or 15 without a career or college goal in mind, they lose interest in school. Different students should be allowed to meet standards and goals appropriate to their aptitudes and interests. School systems should seek to identify each student’s strengths and develop these rather than insist on a single government mandated curriculum. After many years of struggle with false standards and quotas Louisiana has proven that one size does not fit all!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)