Monday, July 2, 2012

Jindal Choice Law: An Invitation to Fraud and Abuse

Note to readers: Soon this blog will carry a report on the voting records of all legislators relative to the Jindal school reform package. At that time I will include suggestions for approaching our legislators about possible repeals or other modifications needed in the laws. Again I am encouraging all readers to submit an email to louisianaeducator@gmail.com so you can be added to my DEFENDERS OF PUBLIC EDUCATION data base. Please include your name and preferred email address and home address so that I can classify all participants according to thier own legislative districts. We have much work to do to save our public education system from destruction. Please be part of this effort!

Key portions of the recently passed Jindal Education legislation are being challenged in court by the LFT, the LAE,  and by the Louisiana School Boards Association. The student scholarship (voucher) program is being challenged on the basis that the state is not authorized by the Louisiana Constitution to fund student enrollment in private schools. These groups are attempting to prevent the implementation of this law before the beginning of the 2012 school year. At this point, the court challenges may be our best hope of preventing the new laws from doing serious damage to our educational system.

In addition to the questionable legality of paying for children to attend private and religious schools, in my opinion, the law is an open invitation to unscrupulous individuals to use our taxes for personal enrichment of a few at the expense of the education of children. This blog has pointed out recent newspaper revelations that several of the private religious schools that had been initially approved for relatively large numbers of public to private “scholarships” apparently did not have adequate facilities, staff or materials of instruction at the time of approval. Superintendent White subsequently assured legislators that private schools offering scholarship seats would be carefully screened to insure that they were capable of providing a quality education program before being given the final go ahead. This policy was obviously created only after the potential abuse was discovered by reporters. (See the new article linked here from the Monroe News Star that incicates that White attempted to mislead the Legislature and the media media about due diligence efforts of the Department!) 

Since private schools are not required to meet accountability standards, such as high stakes tests for promotion and end of course tests as a requirement for graduation, there is no way for Louisiana to insure that our tax money is being used to actually provide quality instruction to students and that the diplomas awarded are valid. There is no way to prevent private school administrators from paying themselves exorbitant salaries while hiring cheap unqualified teachers and charging excessive rent for school facilities using our tax money!

Another portion of the new law inviting possible abuse is the new choice course option. This is an even greater opportunity for fraud and abuse. The provision of Act II that allows students enrolled in public schools to draw upon MFP funds from their school system to attend one or more courses provided by private virtual schools or by private individuals I believe, is another instance of unconstitutional use of public school funds which should also be challenged in court. Meanwhile the state will soon begin to accept proposals from various providers to offer such classes at state expense to students attending public schools rated “C” or below by BESE. The new law provides that such course offerings be approved by BESE by January 1, 2013 so that students may enroll for the 2013-14 school year.

According to the new law, such courses (equal to one Carnage unit) are to be funded at the amount billed by the provider up to one sixth of the MFP funding for the public school system the student attends less 10%. Local school systems are prohibited by the law from discouraging student participation in such courses. (But there is nothing in the law to prevent these private providers from using a portion of our tax support to wage advertizing campaigns aimed at recruiting students from public schools) The law allows students to take vocational or college level courses not provided by their home school but also to take replacements for regular core courses that are already offered by their school if their public school is rated “C” or lower. By passing this provision, the Governor and the Legislature apparently assume that private providers that have little or no track record can provide core courses more effectively than our highly regulated public schools. I believe that the two virtual for-profit schools that are already operating virtual charter schools in the state are uniquely positioned to raid students and critical funding from the public school systems. They already have a major advertizing campaign going to recruit public school students. While their BESE approved charters limit the number of students they can enroll in the two charters, this new law increases their pool of potential students taking numerous virtual courses by tens of thousands!

The “choice course” option amounts to an open invitation for for fraud and abuse by unscrupulous operators. The greatest flaw in this hastily adopted legislation is the provision that 50% of the funding be paid to the provider at the first attendance reporting period on October 1 of each year. There is no provision in the law for reimbursement of any of this 50% in the event that the student does not attend the course after the initial reporting period. The experience of virtual schools provided by K-12 in Colorado is that many students who initially enroll in the virtual program end up dropping out early and re-enrolling in local public schools. This allows the virtual school provider to keep state funds while the local school system which lost the funding is still required to provide the education. Because of the nature of virtual schools, it is almost impossible for the state to enforce the mandatory attendance law. There are clear checks for attendance and guaranteed instruction in a traditional public school, yet it may be almost impossible to check to see of students are doing the required work in a virtual school. Such schools could easily become diploma mills. The opportunities for abuse are almost limitless. It is critical that BESE adopt safeguards to prevent abuse of this section, but in my opinion is there is no way to monitor these programs effectively.

The primary rationale used by the Governor and his supporters for public to private “scholarships” or “choice courses” is that parents are the best judges of the best educational program for their children. Not only is there no evidence for this conclusion, but it must be noted that the money being spent by these parents on scholarships or choice courses is not their money. It is the public's money. Some choice parents may have paid only a small portion of the tax money allocated to the scholarship for their student. Public school funding is provided by all taxpayers; even those who have no children in school. Those other taxpayers have a right to demand that their money is used properly and not wasted or paid to fly-by-night-providers. The problem is that big money and the profit motive could soon fuel major advertizing campaigns that can cause parents to make poor choices with our tax dollars.

My opinion is that the opportunities and the incentives for fraud and abuse in the "choice" programs are so great that no safeguards implemented by BESE or the Department of Education will be adequate to insure proper use of our tax dollars. It is ironic that those who want less government involvement in our lives will eventually be forced to fund a huge regulatory bureaucracy or accept serious misuse of tax dollars. Jindal, in the name of education reform, and in his determination to replace public schools with private providers has created a regulatory nightmare.

I want to refer my readers again to the Recall Jindal website for the most current information on recall efforts on both Governor Jindal and certain legislators. I encourage all my readers to participate in the recall efforts. There can be no justification for the harm done to public education  and to the teaching profession by the Governor and his allies in the recent legislative session. Recall is a legitimate tool of opposition!




Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Renewed Perspective

Note to my readers: Just in case you wondered why there has been a pause in posts on this blog I wanted my readers to know that I took a break from blogging to travel out West. I traveled to Yosemite and other great sites and enjoyed this and other wonderful natural wonders in the western part of our country. I believe that an appreciation of the lasting beauty of nature is a great way to remind us that the puny actions of man are often not very important in in the grand scheme of history.

Meanwhile I am pleased to refer my readers to several prolific education and political writers who have done a great job in the last few weeks of chronicling the recent developments in Governor Jindals' erratic and poorly planned education reform program. I particularly want to refer my readers to the new blog by Diane Ravitch. Dr Ravitch has produced several revealing posts in the last few weeks exposing the many flaws in the Jindal program which will damage public education in Louisiana. I hope my readers will go to her blog and take the time to get the perspective of one of the few writers who truly understands the critical issues in education and who is willing to tell the truth to all who are willing to listen.

In addition, a very experienced local political writer, Tom Aswell has also written much recently in his blog Louisiana Voice about the many missteps of the Jindal administration on  education and other issues. Finally, I refer my readers to the Geaux Teacher! blog  and the Educators for All blog. These are blogs by local educators who have been intensly involved in trying to counteract the recent attacks on public education. I recommend also that readers check regularly with the Louisiana Association of Educators and the Louisiana Federation of Teachers for the latest news on education. In the coming months I will be consulting with LAE concerning contacts with educators on the critical issues facing educators in Louisiana.

Please allow me a little time to get back to my home base and get reoriented to the continuing development of education issues in Louisiana. I am anxious to restart dialog with our many fine educators, school board members and parents.

My highest priority now will be working with leaders of the Coalition For Louisiana Public Education to prepare a set of suggestions for educators to utilize in communicating with their local legislators concerning needed changes in the reform efforts. I plan to meet with my legislators soon to discuss some of these needed reforms of the reforms. I hope that my readers will do the same.

If you have not already done so, please send me an email requesting to join my Defenders of Public Education data base. Include your address so I can organize members by their legislative districts. I plan to send specific emails to members as issues arise that the Defenders can communicate to their legislators.


Wednesday, June 6, 2012

New Accountability Rules

News Flash, Added 6/7/12: Baton Rouge Advocate finally breaks with Jindal and criticizes his unconstitutional voucher boondoggle and strong arm tactics. Also click here for Diane Ravitch commentary on Louisiana's voucher debacle.

On May 29 the US Department of Education approved Louisiana's ESEA Flexibility Request. This approval means that Louisiana will be given flexibility in the use of ESEA Title I funds and will be granted a waiver from some of the mandates and possible sanctions of the No Child Left Behind Act. This waiver should allow public schools more flexibility in how they utilize Title I funds and may not force schools to implement programs and practices that have not been found to be ineffective in improving student performance.

According to Dr. Scott Norton, head of Accountability for the State, schools will now be exempted from some of the burdensome regulations and reporting requirements of No Child Left Behind.

In order to be granted ESEA flexibility, Louisiana had to submit a plan for improving student performance, evaluating teachers partially based on student performance, and implement plans for closing the gaps in student performance. This ESEA Flexibility Request contains major changes in Louisiana's Accountability system that will impact all public schools. The following are some of the major changes in Accountability that will take effect in the 2012-13 school year.
  1. The School Performance Score (SPS) system will be changed from a 200 point system to a 150 point system and the following schedule will determine school grades: 50-69.9=D, 70-84.9=C, 85-99.9=B, 100-150=A.
  2. The SPS system will no longer consider school attendance by students in calculating the SPS for elementary and middle schools.
  3. Dropout rates in grades 6-8 will go from a weight of 10% to 5% in the calculation of SPS.
  4. Each school with a B rating or less for the previous year is expected to grow its SPS by 10 points per year.
  5. Schools where at least 35% of students in new super subgroups (comprised of minority and low performing student groups) exceed value-added expectations will be awarded bonus points on the SPS system.
  6. The greatest changes in the SPS system will occur in the high schools (grades 9-12) where the new SPS will be determined by 4 factors: 25% based on the ACT average score for all students, 25% based on the end of course test results, 25% based on the graduation index, 25% based on the cohort graduation rate.
  7. Any school below B that does not grow by at least 10 SPS points in a particular year must participate in mandatory COMPASS training.
I hope you have time to review the critique of the Louisiana ESEA Flexibility Request by the Louisiana Association of Educators. This letter to John White dated Feb. 28, 2012 and also sent to the USDOE explains what LAE believes are serious deficiencies in the  flexibility request. LAE believes that valid concerns of educators were ignored and a very impractical accountability plan continues that places the entire burden for student performance on educators and none on parents and students. The Association pointed out that the new accountability plan would result in more pressure being put on teachers to teach to the test. LAE also pointed out that school takeover which is continued in this new plan has not been successful in turning around low performing schools and should not be used.

I want to express my appreciation to Joyce Haynes, president of LAE and to Mary Washington, the LAE representative on the Accountability Commission for allowing me to attend the Accountability Commission meeting as their representative at the meeting of May 29.

This Commission was to have had a major voice in approving the new accountability changes. Frankly I was shocked that the Commission had very little input into the initial proposals to the USDOE. For example, the Commission was apparently never told that Louisiana had been allowed several options for improving student achievement as part of the ESEA Flexibility request.  Superintendent John White instead decided that Louisiana should retain the old goal of 100% student proficiency in ELA and math by 2014. The Commission was  never allowed to consider a much more reasonable alternative that was acceptable to USDOE. I can only conclude that Jindal and White were only concerned with the PR value of such irresponsible goals and not at all with the guaranteed perception of failure this causes to be assigned to most of our public schools.

Members of the audience of the Commission meeting pointed out that requiring the ACT of all students in high school would not be appropriate and may result in distorted or unfair school performance scores.

In the course of the meeting I questioned Jessica Baghiam, (formerly JessicaTucker) the young consultant who helped draft the ESEA Flexibility plan, about the mandatory COMPASS training for schools not meeting the new 10 point SPS growth requirement. I asked if this mandatory training may amount to punish work for the teachers in such schools where they would be required to stay after school for failing to achieve an almost impossible goal. She assured the Commission that this was not the intent of the rule. But no one assured us that teachers would not be required to participate in such extra work without pay.

Later that day we heard that the USDOE had approved the ESEA Waiver request. Approval by BESE apparently will simply be a formality.